I like the second red one too, mostly for the pattern in the background. TO SEPARATE MYSELF FROM RENA in opinion though, while the color is 'deeper' than the first one, it's also kind of brighter? I dunno, I've always been a fan of keeping my blacks black, or at least dark. I liked how your current set- while being blue, was definitely dark, so I might appreciate the color on the first one more as it seems more 'dark', but it also seems kind of faded, which I don't care for much but that's just my taste. :/